BRAKE SYSTEM CALCULATIONS
By Dave Mumert
Don't get too excited about wider drums and bigger pads.
The formula for brake torque on a disk
brake system is
Torque = (Brake Pressure) X (Piston
Area) X (Effective Rotor Radius) X (Pad Coefficient of friction) X 2
Notice there is no mention of pad area. The coefficient of friction (u)
is measured in force per square inch per pound of pressure
So a 80 mm caliper (about 7.8 square inches) with 1000psi of
brake pressure will put 7800 pounds of force on each pad.
A 10 square inch pad will have
7800/10=780 pounds per square inch - so force will be 780 X u X 10
square inches or 7800u
A 12 square inch pad will have
7800/12=650 pounds per square inch - so force will be 650 X u X 12
square inches or 7800u
Larger
pads should last longer and may fade less but they don't provide more
brake torque. The same applies to wider shoes on the rear.
You can get more braking by:
1 - Increasing brake pressure - not easy without changing the booster
2 - Increasing pad friction - pretty easy
3 - Increasing rotor diameter - very difficult
4 - Increasing caliper piston size.
Going to 80mm calipers
and rear disks may force you to use a larger bore master cylinder which
will reduce your available brake pressure.
Here is the actual spread sheet so that
you can vary some of the assumptions
(load this file and run it in Excel)
GMCBrakeCalcs.xls
If you are serious about brakes you should
get some reading material and be sure you understand what is involved.
http://www.amazon.ca/Brake-
I'm with you on this, the rear brakes need
some help. I would look at sticky pads (see Jim K) and maybe a
hydra boost system. The system to get rid of the brake torque
from the bogie arms looks like a good place to start. (see Jim
K)Dave M
FRONT | REAR | |
1 | 70MM calipers | drums with asbestos shoes with standard 15/16" slave cylinders |
2 | 80MM calipers | drums with asbestos shoes with standard 15/16" slave cylinders |
3 | 70MM calipers | drums with Carbon Metallic shoes |
4 | 80MM calipers | drums with Carbon Metallic shoes with 1 1/8" slave on middle bogey/15/16"slave on the back |
5 | 70MM calipers | drums with asbestos shoes on the rear bogey with 15/16" slaves, Disk brakes with asbestos or carbon metallic pads on the middle bogey |
6 | 80MM calipers | drums with asbestos shoes on the rear bogey with 15/16" slaves, Disk brakes with asbestos or carbon metallic pads on the middle bogey |
7 | 80MM calipers | Disk brake package installed on both rear bogeys with asbestos or carbon metallic pads |
7. This setup uses several combos of Calipers on the back bogey, one would be using the Cadillac 70mm with the mechanical parking brake or the 70mm calipers from the front of the coach or from the 1984 BOP cars. By the way BOP means Buick/Oldsmobile/Pontiac. An 80MM is used on the middle bogey and is the same unit that was used on the front brakes.
The disk brakes could be the Cadillac Eldo system, Harrison brake system, TSM or others
As for master cylinders the stock unit will work with most applications. The installations with the larger slave cylinders and calipers would benefit from the use of a Chevy P-30 master cylinder that has more volume.
This list is by all means is not complete and many other parts have been used to modify and update the GMC's braking systems.'
You need to understand what you need before you start. Most
people
that have done the cad rear brake conversion do not use the cad
calipers
with the emergency brake feature. It has a tendency not to
release and the rear brake stays locked. The base set up is the
80MM
calipers on the front and middle bogey and the 70MM on the rear.
The 70mm are the same unit that the front uses as stock. As
for an
emergency brake some use a line lock valve that you set when you
push
down on the brakes. I recommend the carbon metalic pads on all
locations
http://www.gmcmotorhome.com/commodore/front_brake/index.html
http://gmcgreatlakers.org/GMCGreatLakers/Technical/CadDisk-Brakes/GMC%20Disk%20Brake%201.html
The second shortcut has a parts list near the end.
If you decide that you what to use the cad rear calipers with the
brake
lever you must find and old set to use as a trade in because you need
the spring and arm assembly to hitch up the cable. The rebuilt
units do not come with the spring and arm assembly and they are
difficult
to
buy. Take a good look at all the pictures. J.R. Wright
*************************
As most all of us have changed the master cylinder, you would have a spare lid. I braised on a nipple to feed fluid under pressure from a can. You don't need much pressure. If you have too much, the top will leak. I have that top to loan , if anyone wants to use it. Dean Hanson
This note came through over the GMCnet and no one commented. Yet it is one of the great ideas of the year. GMCs are known to be difficult to bleed the brakes. The combination of Gravity and Brake Peddle seem to be the most successful but requires a lot of patience and is a two person job. Pressure bleeding has been used for years by manufacturing and truck and brake shops. The problem is getting the proper equipment. This is a low cost way to build your own Pressure Brake bleeding system. The really keen part of this tool, is the siphon to return the fluid to normal level after filling.
This is especially useful when you want to flush all the fluid in the whole system. It takes a lot of fluid and a lot pumping if you are using the brake peddle.
Click here to
read
about:
The Making of the
Inexpensive Brake Pressure Bleeder
I would add only one feature. There used to be a kit that was
called Easy Bleed. He used a spare tire (could be one of those
Mickey
Mouse skinny spares) for the air source. This has the advantage
of
a large volume of air at a constant pressure that you can set with your
air compressor. The tire will have enough air to do the whole
rig.
Gene
---------------
One advantage of pressure bleeding is that master cylinders often seem
to have a tendency to fail soon after brakes are bled bny pumping the
pedal.
That is due to people pushing them all the way down to the floor when
opening
the bleeder valves. This allows a portion of the master cylinder
seals to ride farther down into the bore than they normally
would.
Sometimes there is surface residue on the bores in this area that can
scuff
the seals and then they will subsequently begin to leak.
If one is going to bleed by having someone pump the brake pedal, it is a good practice to put a 3/4" board on the floorboard under the pedal so that the pedal can never go all the way to the floor. Emery
I used Super Blue Racing Brake Fluid.
http://www.shotimes.com/SHO3brakefluid.html
Color of the fluid is Blue, so that as you bleed, when it turns to blue, you know that the old stuff has passed out. Building the Bleeder was the hardest part of the project.....my old hoses came off easy....lucky me!! Larry :-)
2 ea
Banjo
bolt, p/n 313940, $1.99
1 ea
Caliper,
left side, p/n 90185, $12.99 + core charge ($17.00)
1 ea
right side, p/n 90184, price same as above
4 ea
Caliper mounting bolt, p/n H5004, $1.29
1 ea
Brake pad set, p/n 1534, $37.99 (these are Performance Friction carbon
metallic pads)
1 ea
Flexible hose, left side, p/n 77320, $24.99,Wagner F110424,NAPA
38563-702
1 ea
right side, p/n 77421, price same as above,Wagner F110425,NAPA
36954-726
For the brake hoses, try Raybestos # BH38563 & BH36954. You will
need
two
5/8 national fine jam nuts to attach the hoses to the bracket at the
frame.
You will have to slightly alter and move the bracket that is in the
middle
of the hose. The steel tube end that fastens to the caliper will have
to
be
bent a little to clear the upper ball joint.Denny
2 ea
bracket clip, p/n H1457, $1.29
2 ea
jam nut (don't have AutoZone number for this)
2 ea
bolt and nut, ss, ¼ x 1" (not an AutoZone item)
One of the benefits of going with an 80 mm caliper is it applies, I'm told, approximately 1000 psi more braking force vs. original caliper. The difference is noticeable.
Although there was some degree of controversy on this subject a
number
of months back, you may want to consider going to a larger master
cylinder
if making the switch to larger the calipers. If so, it's
available
from
Autozone, p/n 10166, $53.43, and does require an ~ 0.010" longer brake
rod (p/n GM 5469384)(between master cylinder and brake booster) as well
as a modified mounting bracket. If you need further details on
this
modification, let me know. Paul Bartz
The brake light that comes on in the lower right of the round
Gauge Cluster (fuel gauge at top) is not parking brake related
but
it is truly a brake warning light and should not be
ignored.
It is triggered by the proportional valve located on the left
frame
behind and above the driver's side front wheel. The
proportional
valve has brake lines going into it from the master cylinder and
out to the front and rear calipers and wheel cylinders.
There
is an internal sliding valve that should normally be centered. If
the pressure is lower in the front brake circuit the valve slide
forward and the switch grounds the wire coming into the top of
it.
The same thing happens when the back brake circuit has lower
pressure.
Marlene -- try pulling the wire clip off the top of the
proportional
valve (turn on your key) and with it disconnected the brake light
should go out. When you ground it to the frame or other
ground
it should light. It may be that you've got a short in the
wire
somewhere or you might actually have a brake problem. A
sticking
wheel cylinder could cause this. A faulty proportional valve
could
also be the problem. Internal leak in the master cylinder or just
air in the system somewhere. If you have never replaced the
front hoses you should try that first. They have a history
of collapsing internally. This could cause a higher
pressure
in the front brake circuit and trigger the light. Bleed the
master cylinder and then all the wheel lines.
Emery Stora
---------------------------
Leigh Harrison
- uses a huge rotor on the center axle(15 inch<?>) which
requires
a
backspacer to move the rotor inboard
- complete "bolt-on" kit
- all components cad plated
- Expensive(quality costs)
- Requires P30 master cylinder
TSM
- Less expensive
- Works with original master cylinder
- Not really a "bolt-on" - if you don't get the optional braided rear
hoses you must come up with an acceptable way to plumb
the calipers
and the braided hoses are not that great either.
- Currently limits you to a 60mm caliper
-----------
I suggest that you look at Bill Harvey's write up on the GMC
Western States web site:
http://www.gmcws.org/tech.htm#2
Also check out Heinz Wittenbecher's complete instructions on the TSM
system at:
http://www.my-gmc.com/rear.htm
Heinz later changes to the Harrison system. You can see info on that at:
http://www.my-gmc.com/Harrison%20Brakes/album1.html
Heinz points out that there was nothing wrong with the TSM system but since the Harrison system uses larger calipers he wanted to try them. One of the big differences is cost.
I have had the TSM system in for about 2 years now and am very pleased with it. I have towed my CJ-7 Jeep (over 4000 pounds of tow weight) up and down many mountain grades and the disk brakes perform extremely well. I don't have an aux. braking system on my toad and I had experienced brake fade and vapor lock with the drum brake system even while using the asbestos brake shoes that I had bought from Cinnabar and I also had to adjust the brakes frequently due to shoe wear, but I have had absolutely no problems once I switched to the disk brakes.
When I installed the disks I had a hard time bleeding the rear
brakes.
It turned out to be a capacity problem with the master cylinder.
The four calipers just take a lot more fluid than four stock wheel
cylinders.
My solution was to put on a larger master cylinder as shown on my
PhotoPoint
site:
http://albums.photopoint.com/j/AlbumList?u=209754
After installing the larger master cylinder they rears bled easily.
Cost was definitely a factor in my decision to use the TSM brake system. I used their Cadillac rear calipers with the parking brake levers since I wanted to use my stock parking brake lever. This is a slightly smaller caliper than the mid axle ones but they seem more than adequate for stopping the GMC even when pulling a heavy toad. I modified the parking brake cable system to use pulleys instead of the wire guides that cause a lot of drag on the cable. If anyone needs details on those mods, let me know.
Jim Anstett has done an excellent job on getting the stock drum
system
to work about as well as it can, but I just feel that the advantages of
disk brakes are really great. Easy to check the pad thickness
just
by looking at them without disassembling anything, very easy to quickly
replace the pads when needed, no need to periodically adjust the rear
brakes,
and no fade or vapor lock due to the cooling running inherent in the
design
of disk brakes. It is no accident that manufacturers install all
wheel disk brakes on modern, high tech vehicles.Emery Stora
---------------------------------
76-78 Eldorado rear disk brakes
Another alternative is the "roll your own" using 76-78 Eldorado
rear disk brakes.
OEM.....
-------------------------------------------------------------
Combination Valve (Brass) GM #25509419
Front brakes
Front Calipers OEM
(not over size)
Brake
Pads
Carbon Metallic (Performance Friction Co) P/N 0524
(about
$40)
New
Hoses
????? Long Toronado (2) BH36675
Rotors can be obtained from
Cinnabar for $125 each 1-800-720-2227
Rear Brakes
Mid Axle
Cyl
1 1/16" Wagner F79767
Rear Axle Cyl
15/16" Wagner F51081 OEM Size
2 sets Brake Shoes Asbestos
Only
GM #8020290/Delco -- BUY FROM GATEWAY--
Springs
#171-500
DISK BRAKE RETROFIT
-------------------------------------------------------------
P-30 master cylinder
Autozone, p/n 101668, $53.43, and does
require an ~ 0.010" longer brake rod
(p/n GM 5469384)(between master cylinder
and brake booster) as well as a
modified mounting bracket.
or
Wagner P/n
F79821
$60
DISKS, FRONT....
Parts, from Autozone front
wheels are:
2 ea Banjo
bolt,
p/n 313935, $1.89
1 ea Caliper, left
side,
p/n 90185 , $12.99 + core charge($17.00)
1 ea Caliper, right
side,
p/n 90184 , price same as above
4 ea Caliper, mounting
bolt,
p/n H5002 , $3.39
1 ea Brake pad
set,
p/n 1534 , $37.99 (these are Performance Friction carbon metallic
pads)
1 ea Flexible hose, left
side, p/n 77320 , $24.99
1 ea Flexible hose, right
side, p/n 77421 , price same as above
2 ea Flexible hose, bracket
clip, p/n H1457 , $1.29
2 ea Flexible hose, jam
nut (don't have AutoZone number for this)
2 ea bolt and nut, SS,
¼
x 1" (not an AutoZone item)
DISKS,REAR....
Eldo proportioning valve between mid and rear axles. (Approx $35.00)
.... 76-78 Cadillac El Dorado rear wheel backing plates ....
One option for converting to rear disc brakes is using
76-78 Cadillac El Dorado rear wheel backing plates
as the basis to mount the caliper's and elimination of
the dust shield on the backing plate is required,
as well as a slight notching of the backing plate to clear
the swing arm. The backing plate mounting bolt
holes do not need to be enlarged or moved. Machining is
only required to allow the backing plate to fit over
the axle shaft by enlarging the center hole (2.250" with
a 45 degree by 1/16" chamfer on the back side).
*** CAUTION ***
*** The Front Bogie Backing plates NEED to be
strengthened/Reinforced.
***
*** Especially if 80mm calipers are used. Lots of torque
here. ***
The back bogie can use the stock plates/calipers w/parking
brake.
The rotor requires locating and drilling three new holes (same size as existing) for the mounting bolts.
Additional parts, from Autozone rear disc brakes
on the rear wheels are:
2 ea Banjo
bolt,
p/n 313940, $1.99
1 ea Caliper, left front rear
axle,
p/n 90185, $12.99 + core charge ($17.00)
1 ea Caliper, right front rear
axle,
p/n 90184, $12.99 + core charge ($17.00)
1 ea Caliper, left rear rear
axle,
p/n 90557, $73.94 + core charge ($70.00)
1 ea Caliper, right rear rear
axle,
p/n 90553, $73.94 + core charge ($70.00)
1 ea caliper
bolt
p/n H5004 @ $1.29
8 ea mounting
bolt,
p/n H5002, $3.39
1 ea Brake pad set (front rear axle),
p/n 0524, $26.99 (these are Performance
Friction
carbon metallic pads)
1 ea Brake pad set (rear rear
axle),
p/n 25265, $6.49 (these are not Performance Friction
carbon metallic pads)
4 ea Flexible
hose,
p/n 77226, $9.99
2 ea bracket, left
side
p/n 3757443, $8.20
2 ea bracket, right
side,
p/n 10257203, $8.20
4 ea bracket
clip,
p/n H1457, $1.29
4 ea jam nut (don't have AutoZone number
for this)
4 ea Brake line, 3/16 x
20",
p/n H320, $2.49
4 ea rotor. p/n 5512, $36.94.
Emergency Brake...
McMaster-Carr (http://www.mcmaster.com/) pulleys.
P/N 3099T52 and they sell for $5.36
Total shipping was $2.17.
CBWoods
--------------------
A very simple and inexpensive improvement to
the brake cable system did improve the holding power of my
brakes.
I replaced the
hooks that hold the cable where it passes through the frame (both
sides)
with heavy
duty pulleys bolted to the clips that the hooks were attached to. I
un-did the
connection on both sides where the cable attaches to the "U" near the
rear wheels,
passed the cable through the pulley and bolted the cable back in place
----- just
enough cable to still make the connection. This eliminates a lot of
the friction in the
emergency brake system. My coach now holds on my driveway and
all of you who have
visited will agree that it is STEEP. If any one is interested
I have a source for
the "perfect" pulley ($12 for the pair). Gary
Let me add a few things that I have been asked on this subject:
1) The "special pulleys" are special only in the sense that
they
fit and are rugged.
The ones I used came from a logging supply store and were marked "Block
Division,
Wichta Falls, Tx, 525#". They are 3" from the center of
the mounting eye to the extremity
of the pulley wheel -- just the right size to mount on the existing
bracket.
They are galvanized laminated construction. Now available from
Scott
http://members.aol.com/adohen1/page/Adohensupply.htm Ahohen Supply Co.
2) The OEM installation of the brake cable had a hook rod on
the
interior of the passenger
side frame to route the cable away from the OEM muffler. I have a new
muffler system and
this rod is not needed so I removed it. If you need to keep the
rod in order to clear the muffler
then a third pulley can be hung on the rod if it is shortened a few
inches. This will eliminate friction at this point.
3) I think that the "emergency brake" should be more properly
called a "parking brake".
Mine does hold on a fairly steep incline but I have no trouble
overpowering
it with my 455
and I sure would hate to have to depend on it to stop in an emergency
situation.
4) The addition of a vacuum pump to the brake booster is a must in my books.
Gary
Benefits: Great performance enhancer
to the Brake Master Cylinder Kit /
Old Vacuum boosters required 75lbs pedal pressure to activate
valve.
Sensitized Booster initiates valve at 15lbs, and is fully activated at
25lbs pedal pressure.
No sending back your old booster for push rod.
HORROR STORIES OF LOST BRAKES
If your parts supplier can not get a Wagner, then he can cross
reference
to local brand. Don't get stuck with a rebuilt one, not worth
taking
home & small difference if bought Right. This is a perfect
fit
for all '73 thru '78. It's best to bleed the master cylinder on the
bench
before
installation. Better chance of getting all the air out of the
fluid. My Wagner has been on my coach for approximately 9 years w/o any
problems. Coach stops good with OEM brakes & with Brake Guard.
-----------------------
The part # for the new master cylinder for standard brakes is (MC39075)
(NAPA #39705 ). That is a Raybestos number and bolts right
on.
I sell them for $65 no exchange, they are new. You can use your
old
one as a wheel chock!Jim Bounds
----------------------
Sinking Pedal Syndrome
I have not experienced the "Sinking Pedal Syndrome" but have heard
of
several GMCers that have. It's not a bad master cylinder
typically,
but
a bad procedure of bleeding the air out of the master cylinder before
installation (extensive bench bleeding required). What happens
when the
air is not completely removed from the master cylinder is that the
air
will slip past the piston in the master cylinder & the pedal will
slowly
go to the floor. After master cylinder removal & an
extensive bench
bleeding, all is well without exchange of the master cylinder.
I always have done "Bench Bleeding" of a master prior to installation
&
therefore never seen this Syndrome. Next time try to get all
the bubbles
(even the tiny ones) out of the master cylinder prior to installation
&
you will find gone is the Syndrome.
The procedure to determine if you have the "Sinking Pedal Syndrome"
is to
start the engine (Vacuum Booster operating) & press hard on the
brake
pedal for 60 seconds or so & if the pedal starts to slowly sink
then you
have it.
Power of the "Net" illustrated again !!!!. Duane Simmons
------------------
If either set of brakes (front or rear in our case) springs a leak, the corresponding chamber empties, and that piston "bottoms out". If it is the primary piston, it moves down until it physically touches the secondary piston, and now pressure is applied directly to the secondary piston. If it is the secondary chamber that empties, the secondary piston bottoms at the end of the cylinder bore, and pressure builds up between the two pistons in the primary chamber. In either case, THEORETICALLY you still have the remaining half of the brakes. (In fact, the DOT required manufacturers to install a brake warning light to remind the poor befuddled driver that a failure had occurred, since this system worked so well we might not notice the problem otherwise!)
HOWEVER, in the real world it doesn't work that well. Usually the problem is brakes which are out of adjustment, have a little air trapped in lines or cylinders, or spongy hoses, etc. Any/all of these things cause a low pedal. When one of the sets of brakes fails, you lose about 2/3 of the pedal travel before its piston "bottoms out". If the remaining brakes are a bit low/spongy, then the pedal hits the floor before the remaining brakes fully apply. (Your case.) Sometimes pumping the pedal will bring it up enough to work, but the GMC is hard to pump effectively. Also, the GMC brake system works hard even if it's all there, so any failure is more dramatic than in your car.
BTW, the warning light/proportioning valve has little
or
nothing to do with all this, except as another place to trap air
bubbles, or as as a potential leak between front and rear systems
which might circumvent the intended separation.
-------------------
Performance Friction # 524 (0052.10) and #6144 (0614.3) both fit our calipers and the 80 mm.calipersDenny Allen
Front brakes
Front Calipers OEM
(not over size)
Brake
Pads
Carbon Metelic (Performance Friction Co)
Pad
P/N
0524 (about $40)
New
Hoses
????? Long Toronado (2)
BH 36675 is the correct Raybestos number for our coaches. Other numbers
are Wagner F86578, Autozone 88498, Carquest or EIS# SP5363. These also
fit 70-78 Toronados. If the parts guy asks "which side?" the answer is
the right side. The Toronado left hand side ones are to short for our
coaches.
Rotors can be obtained
from
Cinnabar for $125 each 1-800-720-2227
Rear Brakes
Mid Axle Cyl
1 1/16" Wagner F79767
Rear Axle Cyl
15/16" Wagner F51081 OEM Size
2 sets Brake Shoes Asbestos Only
GM #8020290/Delco -- BUY FROM
---------------
Gene, and all who may need this info. I just put new 15/16" Wheel
Cylinders on my 3rd axle.
Here are #'s take right off of the box
Dorman W51081
Which replaces (as noted on the Dorman box)
Coniseal WC13469
Raybestos WC37048
Wagner F51081
Bendix 33469 LARRY 10.27.13
GATEWAY-- #171-500
John Evans 2455eva@pce.net
he has the carbon met shoes,
he also has front pads if you do not have a Autozone, no cores needed
Try calling him at this # 716-652-6868
George.
Springs
New Sets
Combination Valve
(Brass)
GM #25509419
The proportional valve is available at GM Dealers under
part#1236004.
I just got one last month.
They might have to order it. As for bleeding I pulled the valve
out not in. The real question is that do you have air in the master
cylinder
and if you do then you will not get any fluid to the rear brakes.JR
MASTER CYLINDER
-------------
In doing my brakes a few years ago I ran into the poor to very poor
and bad "STAR" adjusters on the rear brakes. This coach is made
to
be self adjusting when you back up. Of course the self-adjusters will
not
work properly or at all if the "STAR" is not in servicable
condition.
chuck